What is the difference between pump gas detector and diffusion?_News_Ningxia Maiya Sensor Technology Development Co., Ltd

What is the difference between pump gas detector and diffusion?

Views：136　Updated：2025-03-28

With Pump vs. Diffusion Gas Detector

1. Working Principle - Pump-Suction Type:
Uses a built-in air pump to actively draw gas samples into the detector for analysis, ensuring controlled sampling.
- Diffusion Type:
Relies on natural diffusion of ambient gas into the sensor, passively detecting environmental conditions. Performance may be affected by airflow, temperature, or humidity.

2.Key Differences

Comparison Criteria	Pump-Suction Type	Diffusion Type
Sampling Method	Active pumping (mechanical suction)	Passive diffusion (natural airflow)
Response Speed	Fast (seconds to tens of seconds)	Slower (minutes, dependent on airflow)
Applicable Scenarios	Confined spaces (pipelines, tanks, tunnels), remote/hazardous area sampling	Open areas (workshops, warehouses, labs)
Interference Resistance	High (controlled airflow minimizes environmental impacts)	Low (sensitive to wind, temperature, humidity)
Cost	Higher (pump hardware and maintenance costs)	Lower (simple design, minimal maintenance)
Portability	Bulkier (due to integrated pump)	Compact and lightweight

3. Scenario Recommendations
- Choose Pump-Suction When:
- Testing confined spaces (e.g., sewers, storage tanks, pipelines).
- Rapid detection is critical (e.g., emergency leak investigations).
- Remote sampling is required (using extended probes in hazardous zones).

- Choose Diffusion When:
- Monitoring open areas long-term (e.g., air quality in factories).
- Budget constraints or lightweight equipment is prioritized (daily inspections).
- Stable environments (no strong wind or extreme conditions).

4. Extended Considerations
Accuracy: Pump-suction types may offer better long-term stability by reducing sensor contamination.
Battery Life: Pump-suction detectors typically have shorter runtime due to pump energy consumption.
Maintenance: Pump-suction models require regular filter cleaning and potential pump replacements.

Pump-suction detectors excel in high-risk, confined, or time-sensitive scenarios, while diffusion types suit cost-effective monitoring in open, stable environments. Selection should balance detection needs, environmental factors, and budget constraints.

【Home】【Return】

Prev：How to calibrate a gas detector?

Next：How far can a gas detector monitor?